Was this sent to you? Subscribe here so you don't miss the next one.
Dept. Dispatch #002
Filed Under: The Lighthouse Trap, Creator leverage layers & Burnout loop
9:00 AM. Coffee-stained table. Overstimulated brain… Tomato Jam?
I nearly missed my own newsletter deadline. Not because of laziness. Because of long-form overwhelm. You know the type—tabs open like confession booths, each screaming, “you should be doing more.”
But here’s the strange thing: The more content I created this week, the more invisible I felt.
And I realized… it wasn’t just me.
It was The Trap.
Enjoy this.
Smell the metaphorical ink.
Share it if it scars you.
DM me if it sparks you.
I’m lurking on…
LinkedIn, X, and Instagram. Probably too much.
Now, let’s talk about the trap we didn’t know we were walking into.
🧩 Memos to the Movement: “Why Giving Too Much Value Hurts Your Sales”
Somewhere between 2018 and the pandemic-era Zoom boom, creators were handed a golden rule:
“Give value. Then give more. Then give even more.”
It worked… until it didn’t.
By 2022, the floodgates opened.
Everyone had a funnel. Everyone was a coach. Everyone offered “life-changing value” in the form of 47-slide carousels and unhinged email threads.
But a strange phenomenon began to surface—no one wanted to buy anymore.
Instead, we saw:
- Sky-high impressions, dry DMs.
- More freebies, fewer conversions.
- Audiences who knew everything... and bought nothing.
Why? Because when everyone gives, nothing feels valuable.
Even Cal Newport warned us:
“In the attention economy, what gets attention isn’t what’s good—it’s what’s rare.”
That’s when I stumbled on it. The trap that almost broke my previous business.
And now, I call it…
THE LIGHTHOUSE TRAP.
“
It’s what happens when you shine so brightly with free content that your audience learns to sail on their own—without ever needing to dock and pay.
It’s not just bad marketing. It’s reverse signaling.
The more you explain, the less you’re perceived as an expert.
The more you give, the more it feels like that’s all there is.
Authority in sales isn’t built through generosity—it’s built through curated restraint.
“Experts don’t explain. They invite.”
Think about it:
- Professors don’t cold-DM students.
- Luxury brands don’t “educate”—they hint.
- The most in-demand creators? They’re hard to reach and even harder to decode.
Authority isn’t about shouting the loudest. It’s about being the signal everyone else tunes into.
A quiet lighthouse, not a blaring foghorn.
Escape the trap by reading the full breakdown below.
💡 Filed Reports
Missed this week’s research drops? Here’s what’s bubbling:
1. The Truth About Creator Economy Leverage
This game isn’t about effort—it’s about asymmetry. The best creators don’t run “businesses.” They compound bets. Here's how they're playing chess while you're playing Duolingo.
👉 Read it here.
2. How to Build a Sustainable Creator Business (Without Burnout)
Post less. Profit more. Sound fake? It’s not. This blueprint unpacks how to turn your knowledge into scalable offers—without bleeding your soul on social media.
👉 Read it here.
3. The One Mistake That Traps 95% of Creators in Burnout
And no—it’s not “not niching down.” It’s something far sneakier. Think: death by selfless generosity.
👉 Read it here.
4. Creator vs Operator: Which One Are You?
Your energy profile determines your business model. Use this matrix to stop fighting your nature and start scaling with it.
👉 Read it here.
🔍 Inside the Dept.
If this were a spy movie, this would be the audio log.
I’m writing from the lab. Traction is weird.
Instagram’s quiet. Twitter’s glitching.
But I’ve got about ten essays in the vault—and that means short-form content is about to explode.
The Content Pasta Machine™ is warming up.
Meanwhile, I’m learning more about automation, retention, and IP structure than I ever did in my last business.
Back then, I just survived.
Now? I’m mapping what scales.
And last week, I got proof—someone booked a consulting call based on one essay. No lead magnet. No CTA.
Just ideas.
🧠 The Info Edge
Here’s what they won’t tell you:
The creator economy doesn’t reward authenticity—it rewards perceived transformation.
People don't buy when they understand you.
They buy when they believe you understand them better than they understand themselves.
Your audience doesn’t need more ideas.
They need elegant synthesis.
They want structure, not saturation.
Signal, not sludge.
“
“Most content online is an echo chamber with no acoustics.”
– a fake quote I made up that feels too real
This week’s memo:
Stop building authority.
Start behaving like you already have it.
🧾 TL;DR for the Lazy Genius:
- You might be losing sales by giving too much free value.
- Audiences now equate abundance with mediocrity.
- Mystery builds authority.
- The Lighthouse Trap = shining so bright your buyers sail away.
- Creator leverage comes from IA design—not posting more.
- The game isn’t about effort but about asymmetry.
🗣️ Help Me Build This Thing
Let me know which direction to push this:
- More behind-the-scenes?
- More case-study heavy?
- More failures + frameworks?
- More spicy commentary on the creator economy?
Reply and say hi.
This is just Day 9 of 100. We’re building in the margins, not the mainstream.
—Sudhanshu “Behaving like crazy genius” Pai
Chief Info Creator
PS - If you've gotten any value from this newsletter, I'd be honored if you'd leave a testimonial so others know this content is valuable.
Did someone forward this to you? Get the free invite here.
